2026-07-30 · contested story

'Woke' Smithsonian exhibit lionizes embattled Fauci amid conservative scrutiny of museum's messaging

The Smithsonian Institution, particularly its National Museum of American History, has become the center of an escalating political firestorm. The Trump administration released a scathing July 4 report accusing the museum of 'extreme political activism' and failing to celebrate America's founders during the nation's 250th anniversary. President Trump ordered warning signs placed outside the museum cautioning visitors about 'inaccurate' exhibits. Congressional hearings followed where Republican lawmakers grilled museum director Anthea Hartig over exhibits featuring transgender advocates, BDSM attire, and race-focused narratives while allegedly marginalizing founding fathers and traditional American history. Left-leaning outlets like NPR and The Washington Post framed the controversy as Republican 'attacks' on a nonpartisan institution, with NPR portraying GOP critiques as 'buffoonish' and emphasizing Democratic defenses. Center outlets like BBC and local news reported the facts more neutrally, noting both the administration's accusations and the Smithsonian's rebuttals. Right-wing sources like Fox News, The Washington Times, and NewsBusters presented detailed evidence of ideological capture, highlighting Hartig's refusal to define 'woman,' exhibits promoting 'woke' ideology, and the hiring of former Democratic staffers and DEI advocates into leadership positions. The story encapsulates broader culture war battles over how American history should be presented in taxpayer-funded institutions.

How each side frames it

left
"did not delve into the details of the Republican arguments against the Smithsonian, but muddled their points into crude accusations to make the conservative criticism sound buffoonish"
"Hartig, who kept a cool tone throughout the hearing, eventually replied: 'So the Smithsonian is a nonpartisan institution we're very proud of.'"
"Many of the Democrats who spoke at the hearing linked the July 4 report to what they perceive as broader GOP attacks on museums, the arts and education."
"We will not let you destroy that museum, no matter how long it takes, how many battles are required, how much effort is needed. We will not allow that to happen unless you find a way to kill all of us and walk over our bodies to change history."
"The hearing itself unspooled on strict partisan lines."
center
"President Donald Trump has ordered signs to be placed outside the Smithsonian National Museum of American History, to caution visitors about exhibits his administration views as 'inaccurate'."
"The Trump administration has often accused the Smithsonian Institution, the world's largest research museum, as well as other academic organisations of harbouring an anti-American bias. The Smithsonian did not immediately respond to the BBC's request for comment."
"A Fox News Digital review of public biographies and social media profiles identified roughly two dozen individuals employed by the Smithsonian in leadership positions or as curators who worked for Democratic offices or progressive nonprofits before being hired."
"The Smithsonian is a nonpartisan institution, and politics does not factor into our hiring practices. Our hiring is solely based on qualifications to fulfill the responsibilities of any given position."
"The order on Friday - titled Restoring Trust in the Smithsonian Institution - accuses museum leadership of not doing enough to celebrate America's founders on the country's 250th anniversary of independence, which took place on 4 July."
right
"South Carolina Representative Nancy Mace grilled Hartig over a number of LGBTQ-promoting exhibits, including one that depicts BDSM attire. The museum was striving to represent 'queer pedophiles, indoctrination, grooming of kids,' Mace argued. 'You sexualize the American history museum.'"
"Hartig refused to define what a woman is. South Carolina Representative Nancy Mace grilled Hartig over a number of LGBTQ-promoting exhibits"
"Culture is not passed on in the bloodstream. It must be taught, curated and loved enough to be handed down. National museums do not exist merely to display objects."
"Roshni Lal, the director of the Smithsonian's office of academic appointments and internships, which oversees academic hiring and internships, has had a career-long commitment to advancing DEI in hiring"
"The headline should have read, 'Lawmakers expose lead Smithsonian historian as leftist ideologue.'"

What each side left out

The left left out — covered by the Fox News & WFIN & The Washington Times
The left left out — covered by the WFIN & The Washington Times
The right left out — covered by the WFIN & BBC
The right left out — covered by the BBC & NewsBusters
The center left out — covered by the The Washington Times

What's actually true?

[contested] The Smithsonian failed to create any exhibit dedicated to presenting a general narrative of American history or telling the story of any of our founding fathers, the Second Continental Congress, the Declaration of Independence, the American Revolutionary War, or the achievement of independence
[verified] A Fox News Digital review of public biographies and social media profiles identified roughly two dozen individuals employed by the Smithsonian in leadership positions or as curators who worked for Democratic offices or progressive nonprofits before being hired
[verified] Roshni Lal, the director of the Smithsonian's office of academic appointments and internships, which oversees academic hiring and internships, has had a career-long commitment to advancing DEI in hiring
[verified] Hartig refused to define what a woman is
[verified] An exhibit at the National Museum of American History featured transgender advocate Jazz Jennings, a biological male
[verified] The Smithsonian receives more than $1 billion a year in federal appropriations
[verified] Only about 1% of donations made by individuals identifying themselves as Smithsonian employees have gone to Republican committees this cycle
[verified] The Smithsonian's National Museum of African American History and Culture displayed a graphic linking positive traits like hard work, punctuality, and rational thought as presumably unfavorable aspects of white culture

The narrative clash

Nature of Smithsonian's institutional stance
Left: So the Smithsonian is a nonpartisan institution we're very proud of.
Right: These leaders have commandeered an institution that the nation entrusted to them to ensure the transmission and, thus, continuance of American culture and heritage and have perversely turned it into its opposite, a hothouse for anti-American activism
Characterization of Republican criticism
Left: did not delve into the details of the Republican arguments against the Smithsonian, but muddled their points into crude accusations to make the conservative criticism sound buffoonish
Right: Mr. Gonzalez's testimony last week before the U.S. House about how the Smithsonian has gone woke was not just another skirmish in the culture wars. It was an indictment of a taxpayer-funded institution entrusted with the nation's memory.
Exhibit content appropriateness
Left: paraphrased: NPR kept details vague, describing exhibit as mentioning 'gender identity and puberty'
Right: an exhibit at the National Museum of American History featured 'transgender advocate Jazz Jennings,' a biological male
Hiring practices
Left: The Smithsonian is a nonpartisan institution, and politics does not factor into our hiring practices. Our hiring is solely based on qualifications to fulfill the responsibilities of any given position.
Right: A Fox News Digital review of public biographies and social media profiles identified roughly two dozen individuals employed by the Smithsonian in leadership positions or as curators who worked for Democratic offices or progressive nonprofits before being hired.

7 sources analyzed

washingtontimes.com NewsBusters Fox News wfin.com BBC News Yahoo! Search The Patriot Post

Perspectivity reads the coverage — not just who published it.

Read the full interactive analysis →